A new book by Andrew P. McLean, Associate Professor in our top-rated Law School, examines how powerful investment firms are undermining competition across the American economy and calls for stronger action to limit monopoly power.
Titled: Antitrust and the Age of Asset Management, the book has been published by Harvard University Press today.
Growing influence of investment firms
The book explores how the growing power of financial institutions is driving a decline of competition in the United States. Dr McLean highlights two main ways this happens.
One involves private equity firms acquiring multiple businesses in the same industry, a strategy known as a 'roll-up'. Such acquisitions have contributed to consolidation in sectors across the US, in everything from healthcare to ski resorts.
The other involves investment firms holding shares in several companies competing in the same market. This practice, known as 'horizontal shareholding', has grown alongside the popularity of index funds and is linked to concerns about competition in industries such as airlines and agriculture.
Proposals for stronger competition policy
Dr McLean highlights the relationship between finance and market concentration and critiques the failure of competition policy to address these challenges.
The book also contributes to debates about the dangers of an excessively large and influential financial sector.
Dr McLean sets out a series of proposed reforms to tackle consolidation driven by financial firms.
These include banning acquisitions that would allow a private equity firm to control more than 30 per cent of a market.
He also proposes setting a maximum limit on the amount of equity capital that an investor may manage, which would currently stand at around $700 billion (or 1 percent of the S&P 500).
Antitrust and the Age of Asset Management is available to order now from Harvard University Press.
Andrew McLean has done a masterful job of explaining how the financialisation of the US economy and the rise of asset managers have contributed to unhealthy economic concentration and collusion. More importantly, he has thoughtful recommendations for how to address the problems of private equity roll-ups and horizontal shareholding through increased antitrust enforcement, corporate governance reform, and legislation restructuring the financial sector. This is both first-rate research and a very good read.
Find out more