Departmental Research Seminar
Departmental Research Seminar for students and staff
Seminar
Our departmental research seminar talks will take place on Wednesdays during term time from 15:00 to 16:30, in 005, 48 Old Elvet, Durham, DH1 3HN.
Our Speaker this week is Dr Paula Satne (Leeds).
Title: "The Compatibility of Forgiveness and Memory in the Context of Personal Relationships".
Abstract: In this talk, I examine the compatibility of forgiveness and memory in the context of personal relationships, expanding on my account of political forgiveness and public commemoration. While memory in the political realm can impose limits on forgiveness, personal contexts require a more nuanced understanding of the importance and meaning of remembering past wrongdoing. I identify four senses of remembrance: (i) avoiding erasure of the wrong; (ii) retaining (keeping knowledge of the wrong and its significance); (iii) considering (actively reflecting on it); and (iv) reminding (bringing it to another’s attention). I argue that forgiveness in close relationships can coexist with retaining an awareness of a wrong’s significance, since one can do this without holding it against the wrongdoer. However, forgiveness is only sometimes compatible with considering and reminding. This depends partly on the wrongdoer’s attitudes. If the wrongdoer does not accept that what he did was wrong (or believes he was justified), then continuing to consider the wrongdoing amounts to holding it against him, and it remains a source of conflict. If the wrong is accepted, however, continued consideration is compatible with forgiveness. Similarly, whether reminding is compatible with forgiveness depends on whether the wrongdoer accepts being reminded. In political contexts, reminding (i.e. commemorating) has clear moral value, but it is not always important in interpersonal cases. Reminding may sometimes be necessary (e.g. for moral development). However, constant reminders may indicate a lack of generosity or even meanness. By contrast, considering is always important, as it expresses self-respect and helps prevent repeated offences, while forgetting (understood as archiving the wrong’s significance) is always problematic. While forgiveness and retaining are compatible, we should avoid giving wrongdoing excessive importance, as this may lead to rumination and undermine self-respect. My analysis ultimately rejects the view that forgiveness is equivalent to forgetting and instead proposes a transformative engagement with memory that promotes a form of relational healing in which the attitudes of the wrongdoer play a significant role.